Add Vanderbilt to the list of teams that have fallen victim to the claim: “having two quarterbacks is having no quarterback.”
The recipe at quarterback this season has hurt the confidence of both players and the chemistry and flow of an offense that is not recognizable. Despite being put in a position to fail, Jared Curtis has risen above and proven to Commodore nation that he is worth the hype.
Vanderbilt has found its quarterback, and while I could harp on the many things that went wrong in that messy contest to open this column, I want to focus on the importance of Curtis’ emergence.
Because a 19-year-old, expected by the fan base to fill the shoes of the legendary Diego Pavia, has looked beyond the noise — both the media’s obsession with why he’s not starting and Vanderbilt’s student section’s literal boos at halftime — and established that he can be a winner.
The freshman was a bright spot in this affair, and I can’t even blame the student body for the way it reacted at halftime. Boos rained on the Commodores, and those exiting were rained on by “Let’s go Hens.” This was the sloppiest performance I have seen from the Commodores in recent history, with back-to-back drives in the second quarter that resulted in a fumble and then a punt scooped up for 6 points for Delaware.
The Commodores are lucky they didn’t add one to the loss column after today’s matchup, and I commend the team for staying in it despite a disastrous second quarter.
I’m shocked; not necessarily with individual talent or schemes and strategies, but that a group with so many great coaches can play a game this chaotic and careless. There were certainly some positive takeaways, but if the Commodores want any chance of competing with the Georgias, and even NC States of the world, they are going to have to turn up the heat.
I’m going to do my best to compartmentalize my excitement around the freshman quarterback from the mistake-riddled and disjointed football game I watched.
The two-person reservation must be canceled for next Saturday, because the freshman sensation has arrived. Curtis was poised in the pocket, confident and even showed off his running ability. You know that feeling that all Commodores had when the ball was in Pavia’s hands? Everyone trusted him, and despite whatever else happened in the game, No. 2 found a way to win.
This No. 2 certainly did that Saturday afternoon, taking the keys from Berlowitz after two straight punts and capping off his first drive with a rushing touchdown as the Black and Gold took a 7-0 lead. Curtis’ 31-yard tight-window throw to Jayvontay Conner to the 1-yard line foreshadowed his performance throughout the contest, as the quarterback was unafraid to make difficult passes.
Curtis ended up playing the entire second half, completing 14 of his 22 throws for 210 yards and a passing touchdown. The Nashville native also punched in two rushing touchdowns and underscored his ability to evade the pocket and run the football. A trait Berlowitz supposedly had over Curtis was his talent as a rusher — but that disparity doesn’t seem to be quite as large as many expected.
Last week, Curtis entered the game on a two-minute drill at the end of the first half. This week, he was randomly plugged in on Vanderbilt’s third drive. It doesn’t seem like he knows when he’s entering the game, making it all the more impressive that he was ready when opportunities presented themselves.
Playing two quarterbacks makes it tough for the offensive line, wide receivers and especially the quarterbacks themselves to develop any sort of rhythm. However, Curtis’ high-level mechanics and poise in the pocket were on full display, and it looks like he and wideout Junior Sherill have developed a lasting connection. Curtis’ soft spiral fell beautifully into Sherill’s hands on the sideline for a 35-yard gain at the start of the third quarter, which I thought was one of his best throws of the day.
With all of that being said, the freshman was by no means perfect and has a long way to go to live up to his potential. Curtis tends to wait too long in the pocket and needs to be better with reading pressure. Furthermore, he often gets baited by the opposing team’s secondaries and has thrown multiple near-interceptions into tight windows. However, the potential is clearly there, and no matter how unpolished he looks, there is no reason he shouldn’t be in the game. This guy wasn’t the best Vanderbilt recruit in history for nothing; he has the size, instincts, talent and capability to compete on the highest level.
That brings us to Berlowitz, who I can’t help but feel sorry for in all of this. The senior had a rough game to say the least, highlighted by his consequential fumble in the second quarter. He completed just 3-of-9 pass attempts (two of which were drops), for just 29 yards and an abysmal Quarterback Rating (QBR) of 1.8. To put it in perspective, Curtis’ QBR was 65.4.
Anyways, Berlowitz was the starter because he supposedly had more experience and could play safe by protecting the football and making smart plays. The Cushing, Oklahoma, native was never going to outplay Curtis in terms of arm talent. It was all about maturity. This afternoon, his decision-making was poor, and frankly, he looked unprepared and flustered out there.
Berlowitz has to give Vanderbilt a better chance to win football games to be playing any snaps, and he simply does not. It’s weird how when he is taking snaps, there are little calls for him to throw the ball down the field. It seems like offensive coordinator Tim Beck doesn’t trust him to make necessary passes and showcase his talent. Head coach Clark Lea said this week in his press conference that he needed a larger sample size, so why not let them both air it out against Delaware? It’s Delaware; this game should not have been competitive, and the reason I say it’s not Berlowitz’s fault is that it doesn’t feel like he’s been put in a position to show what he can do. A quarterback constantly worried he is going to be pulled from the game results in passive play.
Berlowitz is a very solid backup quarterback, but he isn’t the guy. Let’s be honest, he never was the guy. Curtis was, so for the rest of the roster’s sake, and the fanbase, a proper decision needs to be made.
This is an SEC football team, not Pop Warner, and not everyone “deserves” snaps at quarterback. Coach Lea needs to ride with the hot hand, the future and book Curtis a table for one.
There’s a reason nobody goes back for seconds when the first plate was a complete mess. For Commodore fans, they were ready for an entirely different dish at halftime and weren’t afraid to make it known.
Vanderbilt was certainly the more talented team, but I remain surprised at how it escaped with a victory considering so much of it was just sloppy. Mistakes were prevalent for the Black and Gold, who need to clean things up when they begin facing tougher competition.
The Commodores matching up with Austin Peay and Delaware to open their 2026 season was a blessing in disguise, as learning from mistakes is the best way to move forward. Starting off with two victories, Lea and his coaching staff can address these flaws in practice without it actually affecting the ’Dores record.
Let’s dive into that second quarter: many criticized the coaching staff for accepting a penalty on 4th-and-7 with 7:16 left in the second quarter. A Brock Taylor field goal had been made, but the Commodores wanted a chance to convert what was now 4th-and-2. I like that aggressive mentality, and even though it didn’t pay off, it allows Curtis to be put in high-pressure situations, which is exactly what he needs more of to develop his mental game.
What followed that was not pretty, as the Commodore defense gave up a touchdown and then Berlowitz fumbled the football five plays into the following drive. Then, after Berlowitz went three and out, Tyler Ebel was forced to punt right outside his own end zone. The punt was blocked, resulting in a Blue Hen six, and the Black and Gold were down three entering halftime.
The second half was better, with the keys fully handed to Curtis, but each position group had its own shortcomings. Despite leading his team in receiving, Vanderbilt’s No. 1 receiver Sherill had four drops. Other receivers had trouble with drops too, while struggling to create space and make plays after the catch.
The offensive line had a rough outing, with Vanderbilt’s rush attack averaging just 2.6 yards per carry against a lackluster Delaware defensive front. Both Curtis and Berlowitz were under pressure too often and couldn’t rely on the run game to open up the field. On the defensive side, the secondary missed many tackles. Defender after defender couldn’t bring down Delaware’s Da’Wain Lofton off a short pass, resulting in a 57-yard gain. A tackle there would have prevented the Blue Hens’ first field goal at the start of the second quarter.
Vanderbilt’s defense came out of the gate swinging, shutting down quarterback Nick Minicucci early on. Defensive Coordinator Steve Gregory’s unit didn’t play a bad game but has plenty of room for improvement.
Safety CJ Heard and EDGE rusher Miles Capers had some of their best games as Commodores, with both veterans rising to the occasion and making life difficult for Minicucci and company. Capers’ back-to-back big plays on Delaware’s second drive were critical — single-handedly putting the Blue Hens in a grueling 3rd-and-17 situation. The senior tackled Jo Silver behind the line of scrimmage on first down, setting up a 2nd-and-long, and then sacked Minicucci for a loss of six yards.
He went on to record 7 tackles, 4 of which were solo and a masterful 4 tackles for loss. Two drives later, the EDGE remarkably batted the football up, which resulted in a Martel Hight interception. Capers’ ability to make plays on the football in the first quarter is a large reason Delaware remained scoreless after 12 minutes.
Heard led the Black and Gold with a career-high eight tackles, and his five solo tackles were essential for a secondary that struggled to bring Delaware’s pass catchers to the ground. Furthermore, Heard logged his first multi-sack game ever, with two pivotal takedowns — one of which resulted in a fumble from backup quarterback Braden Streeter.
Additionally, linebacker Austin Howard had another great game, giving Vanderbilt a blocked punt for a touchdown of its own. The sophomore blocked Josh Cupitt’s punt at the beginning of the third quarter and somehow came up with the football in the end zone.
Despite Capers, Heard and Howard’s efforts and an impressive first quarter, the Commodore defense still struggled immensely to stop Delaware from moving the football. Gregory no longer has a Heisman finalist on the other end who can put up 30-point performances against NFL-level defenses. This unit will have to set the tone going forward, taking pressure off an inexperienced offense.
The Commodores return to action Sept. 19, hosting NC State on Family Weekend, with kickoff set for 11:45 a.m. CDT at FirstBank Stadium.
The official student newspaper of Vanderbilt University
Your email address will not be published.
Enter the destination URL
Or link to existing content
Subscribe to Updates
Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.
Commodore Brunch Week 2: It’s not always pretty – vanderbilthustler.com
Previous ArticleYankees To Activate Clarke Schmidt On Wednesday
